Academic Publishing Wiki

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 1: Line 1:
 
'''Peer review''' plays an important role in wiki academic publishing. The first rule for peer review at '''<nowiki>academia.wikicities.com</nowiki>''' is that reviewers should always follow the rules established by individual [[List of Journals|wiki journals]]. If an article has been submitted to a journal for peer review, reviewers must follow the peer review rules established by that particular journal.
 
'''Peer review''' plays an important role in wiki academic publishing. The first rule for peer review at '''<nowiki>academia.wikicities.com</nowiki>''' is that reviewers should always follow the rules established by individual [[List of Journals|wiki journals]]. If an article has been submitted to a journal for peer review, reviewers must follow the peer review rules established by that particular journal.
   
Technically, it is possible for an article to be peer-reviewed at '''<nowiki>academia.wikicities.com</nowiki>''' without first being submitted to a wiki journal. This mode of peer review exists as an experimental option. Is it possible for peer review to function without explicit rules and control by a defined community ([[wiki journal]])? In order to try to make this experiment a success, some restrictions are being imposed on the process (see below).
+
Technically, it is possible for an article to be peer-reviewed at '''<nowiki>academia.wikicities.com</nowiki>''' without first being submitted to a wiki journal. This mode of peer review exists as an experimental option. Is it possible for peer review to function without explicit rules and control by a defined community ([[wiki journal]])?
 
===Peer review of articles not submitted to a journal===
 
If you write a peer review article, you '''MUST''' make use of a '''peer review outline'''. In most cases, you should use the peer review outline that is required by the particular journal that the target article was submitted to. If you wish to peer-review an article that has not been submitted to a specific journal, you '''MUST''' use the generic '''<nowiki>academia.wikicities.com</nowiki>''' [[Peer review article outline]].
 
   
 
====Detailed Instructions for the generic Peer review article outline====
 
====Detailed Instructions for the generic Peer review article outline====

Please note that all contributions to the Academic Publishing Wiki are considered to be released under the CC-BY-SA

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)